Interactions with Christian leaders over the last several years in Nigeria, Eastern Europe, and India, have provoked my thinking about issues of race and ethnicity. As I hear stories of Christian ministry in these diverse places, I wonder where racial reconciliation and inter-ethnic peace-making fit in our ideas about “making disciples.” We’re convinced that Jesus’ Commission sends us to make disciples of “all ethnicities”, but I fear that we’re not very clear on the implications of being a disciple on the way we view “others” – especially if a believer has come from a context of ethnocentrism. Where does ethnicity fit as it relates to being a follower of Jesus Christ?
History and the daily news remind us of this tension – whether we’re talking about recent racial incidents involving the police in Cambridge, MA or we’re studying the genocide in the 90’s in Rwanda and Burundi.
Consider three questions, questions that we all must deal with if we desire to build towards that great multi-cultural, multi-ethnic worship service of people reconciled to God and to each other that the Apostle John described.1
How much does our disciple-making need to wrestle with history? On a trip to Bosnia, our host explained that the Serbian aggression in 1989 towards the Muslims was related to an event in 1389. The 600th anniversary had stirred Serbian nationalism. As I heard this story, I thought to myself, “How can someone like me from the USA – whose entire national history is about 1/3 as long as this – teach a Serb to follow Jesus and love those he’s been historically indoctrinated to hate? How does Christian discipleship help people deal with “the leftover debris of their national pasts?”2
Those of us who come from Anglo culture in the USA think little about the past; witness how seldom we who are white want to deal with the lingering issues of slavery or racism or the “ethnic cleansing” of the First Nations Peoples centuries ago. Until we start wrestling with our respective and our collective histories, we won’t really know how to address the historical hostilities we find elsewhere.
History as well can urge us on to greater resolve to preach reconciliation. In light of the fantastic progress of Pentecostalism in the world, I’ve often reminded leaders of their own teaching on the “signs” of the Holy Spirit. William Seymour, key figure in the Azusa Street revivals that precipitated the modern Pentecostal movement, “came to believe that the truest sign of the presence of the Holy Spirit was not speaking in tongues but the demise of racial barriers between Christians.”3
What does it mean to be “one new person” (Ephesians 2)? At the theological foundation of our uncertainty of the relationship of disciple making and ethnicity lies this passage in Ephesians where Paul describes the church as the place where God makes “one new man” out of two ethnically different people. Perhaps we only get people “partially converted” so that they become a saved member of their ethnic specific group, but they never proceed to the point of being made into something totally new – to the point of seeing others who are different as fellow family members in God’s household.
William Barclay’s commentary on the passage sheds light on the “new” idea:
“The word that Paul uses here is kainos; he says that Jesus brings together Jew and Gentile and from them both produces one new kind of person. This is very interesting and very significant; it is not that Jesus makes all the Jews into Gentiles, or all the Gentiles into Jews; he produces a new kind of person out of both, although they remain Gentiles and Jews. Chrysostom, famous preacher of the early Church, says that it is as if one should melt down a statue of silver and a statue of lead, and the two should come out gold.”
What does this new person look like?
What is the role of remembering versus forgetting? In Mostar, Herzegovina, a sign is painted on the Muslim side of the city. It simply reads, “Don’t forget.” The older Muslims don’t want the younger ones to forget the atrocities committed against the by Orthodox Serbs and later Catholic Croats. But if there is no forgiveness and forgetting, the peace between peoples will be at best very tentative. Rather than peace, it will be, in the words of one writer, nothing more than “hatred that is sleeping.”
Miroslav Volf, himself a Croat who suffered under Serbian aggression, wrestles with this role of remembering in order to forgive and move on. He illustrates the goal we are after through the Old Testament character Joseph. Volf writes:
“In the well-known story in the book of Genesis, Joseph was ready to undertake the difficult journey of reconciliation with his brothers who sold him into slavery because, as he put it, ‘God has made me forget all my hardship and all my father’s house’ (41:51). Before coming to an end, the journey of reconciliation entailed a good deal of remembering, however. Joseph himself was reminded of the suffering his brothers had caused, and subtly but powerfully he made them remember it too (42:21-23; 44:27ff.). Yet, like the distant light of a place called home, the divine gift of forgetting what he still remembered – ‘backgrounding’ the memory might be the right term – guided the whole journey of return. Wanting to insure that the precious gift be lost neither on him nor on his posterity, Joseph inscribed it into the name of his son, Manasseh – ‘one who causes to be forgotten.’ A paradoxical memorial to forgetting (how can one be reminded to forget without being reminded of what one should forget?), Manasseh’s presence recalled the suffering in order to draw attention to the loss of its memory. It is this strange forgetting, still interspersed with indispensable remembering, that made Joseph, the victim, able to embrace his brothers, the perpetrators (45:14-15) – and become theirs and his own savior (46:1ff).4
Paul Borthwick serves on the staff of Development Associates International, a training group dedicated to the character and ministry development of leaders in the under-resourced world. Paul teaches missions at Gordon College and serves as an Urbana/Missions Associate with Inter-Varsity Christian Fellowship.
Footnotes:
1. Revelation 5:9 and 7:9
2. Donald Schriver, An Ethic For Enemies p. 7.
3. Quoted in Stephen A. Rhodes, Where the Nations Meet: The Church in a Multicultural World, p. 75, and also noted by Harvey Cox in Fire From Heaven, p. 63.
4. Miroslav Volf, Exclusion and Embrace: A Theological Exploration of Identity, Oneness, and Reconciliation (Nashville: Abingdon, 1996), p. 139.